Ives Quartet
Performance Review
InsideBayArea.com
Tuesday, November 8, 2005
Inside Bay Area: Ives Quartet provides beautiful musical view
By Keith Kreitman, Contributor
I once wrote that the Ives Quartet had the most beautifully rich sound
of any string quartet I had ever heard. Its performance last weekend
at St. Mark's Episcopal Church in Palo Alto seems to have improved
upon that.
With new first violinist Bettina Mussumeli, I wondered whether there
would be a change in the quartet's wonderful sonority, but she fits
right into that family of Susan Freier, second violin; Scott Woolweaver,
viola and Stephen Harrison, cello, as if they were all musical siblings.
Harrison in 1983 was one of the founders of the Ives Quartet as the
quartet in residence at Stanford University. There it remained until
1998, when it declared artistic independence and moved on to the national
and international stages with growing reputation and recognition.
Resting upon the base of Harrison's cello - and he is unsurpassed
by any cellist I have ever heard in richness of tone - it is the group's
control of dynamics and timbre shadings and impeccable phrasing that
is so engaging to
the ear.
In fact, I sat in a location where I couldn't see them bowing, just
to be able to float, without visual distraction, upon that magical
carpet of sound.
Even among the most celebrated of string quartets, one is conscious
of four individual artists performing together. But with Ives it seems
as if there is only one multi-instrumented performer.
And its choice of Franz Schubert's 1824 romantic Quartet in D Minor,
D.810, was just the right vehicle for its sonorous strength.
And as if to prove it could even render dissonances beautifully to
the Romantically trained ear, it opened the program with Arnold Schoenberg's
Quartet No. 2 in F-sharp Minor, Op. 10 and made me realize how this
composer's music, shocking to the musical sensibilities of many of
us, has entered the mainstream.
From 1907, this was one of Schoenberg's earlier, more traditional
works, before he ventured much deeper into atonality. But it still
caused some
dismay.
It was revolutionary, not only by beginning to break away from centuries
of
tonal music but, with the addition of a female voice in the last two
movements singing poems by German Stefan George, it became in effect
a vocal quintet.
Singing in Saturday's performance, Elza van den Heever blended in
as if a fifth member of the family. This native of Johannesburg, South
Africa, ranks among the best. She filled the church with power, but
with never a loss of intonation, throughout her entire vocal range;
her German diction in verse was perfect.
The German translation of Schoenberg's name
is "beautiful mountain" and
he certainly did develop a new and beautiful peak in serious music.
The Ives Quintet with van den Heever climbed it with ease to show
us the beautiful view.
Keith Kreitman is a freelance writer. You can reach
him by calling (650) 348-4327 or by email at rainykeith@aol.com.